Jonathan Trott: A Very Public Illness

I watched the recent return of Jonathan Trott to the England Test team with a mixture of concern and sadness. Trott has had an extended sabbatical from international cricket, following the implosion of his batting in the 2012/13 Ashes series, due to what he described as a ‘stress-related illness’.

It has become clear that this is the favoured catch-all term for a variety of mental illnesses, which are still discussed with a certain coyness in sport. Trott also followed the same sequence of events laid down by Marcus Trescothick, of alternating between denial and acceptance. But while the former England left-hander has since come to terms with his mental illness, albeit at the expense of his international career, that never seemed to be the case with Trott.

The Warwickshire batsman went back to county cricket, left again, rejoined and made hay. He also fared well on a Lions tour and was apparently given an all-clear to return to the crucible of Test cricket by a battery of ECB analysts. Trott’s problems, it seemed, were down to fatigue: Pressure, a failure to live up to his own exacting standards – a crisis of confidence, form and temperament that must have been fearful, disturbing, crippling. A terrible vicious circle. It seems to be a peculiarly male problem: the need to provide, prosper and succeed – the failure of which can be devastating to a psyche that is geared up to those goals.

Trott may have viewed his collapse in Australia as letting down his team-mates, family, employers, captain and even country. That it happened in a public spotlight, under hostile conditions and in circumstances that posed extreme physical dangers must have been a shattering experience. A loss of self-image, self-respect; a loss of self-knowledge. To fail at the one thing at which you truly excel; the thing that defines you as a man must be devastating indeed.

Despite a number of international cricketers speaking publicly about their difficulties with mental illness – Trescothick must receive high praise for paving the way for other to follow – Trott received a good deal of criticism from commentators ill-equipped to understand his situation, yet he must bear some of the responsibility for that reaction.

His various explanations as to exactly what was wrong with him suggested that he was experiencing burn-out. Whether Trott was unaware of what was happening to him or deliberately misleading because he feared the end of his career, or loss of face, is still unclear. But it seemed clear that Trott was experiencing a situational anxiety that was divorcing his mind and body in a game where the ability to sum up a situation and react to it correctly in a split second is vital to success and physical well-being. Any batsman fears getting hit at 90mph by a cricket ball – for reasons that became obvious in late 2014.

The England batsman’s technique has seemed bizarre since that Ashes series and his approach to batting highly unusual. He appears uncertain, his judgement clouded. The surprise is that England chose to back Trott in a position and arena that would expose him to fast, hostile bowling despite the fact the root cause of whatever was behind his exit from the team never seemed to have been addressed – because it had never really been acknowledged.

Amid the England set-up and, to some degree, in the media there seems to have been the assumption that Trott had been ‘fixed’ of the anxiety that seems to have crippled him as a sportsman, in the same way that a torn hamstring or chipped bone can be repaired or rehabbed: a physical injury that will simply go away in time.

It’s not necessarily unhelpful to compare mental illness to physical illness in some ways: it can help others understand that there should be no stigma or shame, nor that mental illness cannot be treated; that it can happen to anyone and can be just as debilitating as a broken arm or ripped muscle.

Yet it can be a double-edged sword – such a broad metaphor can also lead people to assume that anxiety, depression and other disorders can be eradicated, never to return. But old cricketers will bear testament that not all physical injuries vanish forever after a few weeks of rest and rehab: nagging anxiety, self-doubt or depression can reappear without warning, just as bone, skin and joints can tell a story on a cold, wet day years later.

Seeing Jonathan Trott bat again against the West Indies recently, it seems clear that whatever issues or affecting him have not been eradicated. It begs some questions as to how wholly the England Cricket Board and sportsmen generally have really grasped the significance of mental illness in high-pressure environments, or they have understood how enduring and difficult it can be.

On one hand it’s to their credit that Trott was given an opportunity to return to the fold, having met every challenge that could reasonably have been expected of him in representing England again. But while commentators and the bulk of the press corps glossed over Trott’s difficulties, his performances led journalist – and friend of Trott – George Dobell to describe him as ‘broken‘.

It seemed a starkly brutal term, yet it seems hard to disagree with the view that, as a cricketer, the Trott of 2015 is a very different beast from the Trott of 2010: the Trott who compiled vast, serene centuries against the best bowling attacks in the world. The strange, kamikaze walks down the wicket to fast bowlers, alarm at short balls and uncertain shot selection suggest more than a lack of form or luck – they suggest a temperament and technique that had slipped their moorings.

Jonathan Trott was Andy Flower’s ‘rock’. That, in itself, seems to hint at the dichotomies of mental illness and suggests why we’re so poorly-equipped to comprehend and react to it. From ‘rock’ to ‘broken’ in two short years. How is that possible?

Perhaps what the Trott saga indicates most of all is that our lexicon is still lacking when it comes to explaining mental illness. The words that are bandied around – broken, burnout, fatigue – vary between crude and coy. ‘Stress-related illness’, that most famous cop-out, reeks of management-speak. The embarrassment and awkwardness with which these maladies are discussed continue to hold back our understanding of mental illness and that lack of understanding necessarily means a lack of empathy and tolerance towards it.

Jonathan Trott may have been a fine servant for English cricket for several years, but his abortive return to the England team demonstrates the strange omerta over mental illness in sport still holds sway.

Originally written for Opening Up

Why Data Should Drive Your Next Car Purchase

My Q3 2015 column for Professional Manager Magazine

Imagine a car advert. For any brand, for any car. Chances are there are young people involved, enjoying an active lifestyle with their friends or, perhaps, a young family. Here’s what I guarantee you won’t see. Old people. Probably anyone over the age of 40, in fact. Car adverts don’t feature old people, yet older people buy all the cars.

While everything in car advertising might tell you that the markets manufacturers seek most are towards the younger end of the spectrum, it makes sense to keep a healthy customer base in the older bracket. With an ageing population – and the silver pound more disposable – it’s manufacturers who can attract buyers that see value, safety and practicality as key buying factors. Empty nesters – or baby-boomers – are where the easy money is for car-buyers.

What’s more, the amount of young people owning licenses has dropped sharply over the decades. WIth improvements in public transport and private transport such as Uber to the fore there’s not as much pressure on youngsters to buy new cars. Assuming they can afford them – or even want them.

Demographics drive car-building. Their demands, needs, desires and buying power. It’s why we’re now seeing Land Rover making smaller, cheaper cars aimed at the female market such as the Range Rover Evoque; why Lexus, Audi and Mercedes are hoovering up sales in the small family car sector; why BMW is building a front-wheel drive MPV.

Some of the ideas are anathema to some petrolheads, but the requirement for smaller, cheaper, more individual cars from a fragmented public has driven manufacturers to look at different niches, sectors and markets. In a buyer landscape so massively disrupted, manufacturers must adapt to the demands of buyers or die out.

And, though you may not have noticed, it’s happening. The rear-hinged doors on the Vauxhall Meriva, higher seating position, lower boot lids – they’re all aimed at being friendlier to the more mature driver. At the extreme end of the scale you have cars such as the Renault Scenic or Toyota Auris – basically Eastbourne on wheels.

Toyota Auris - Eastbourne on wheels

Toyota Auris – Eastbourne on wheels

Many fleet and business drivers are likely to be what are now called Millennials in the next decade: 18-40-year-olds with a significant interest in music, new technology and assorted media. Tech-savvy and consumption-driven, they’re the perfect audience for the new generation of smart cars.

Let’s not forget another huge tranche of buying power: parents. Women are now more likely to buy family cars primarily used for transporting the little ones to school, gymkhana and ballet classes – so it makes sense that car-makers market directly to them, making a big deal of safety, practicality and versatility. a June 2012 Nielsen survey of visitors to US automotive websites indicated that the 35-64 age group were more likely to be women than men.

Manufacturers don’t always get it right though. Volvo almost underwent the equivalent of a nervous breakdown a few years ago with its misfiring Naughty Volvo marketing campaign. Thankfully order was soon restored and the Swedish brand was back to doing what it does best. But there’s often a sense among manufacturers that they rail against what their data is telling them. The manufacturers that seem most at ease with their brand offering – and their customer needs – tend to prosper.

It’s the same with buying cars for a fleet – and it might give you the wake-up call you need if you’re thinking of plumping for something that is going to be a hard sell to the spouse. Everyone may demand a smart new exec – something German or Italian perhaps – but demographic data may tell another story. Good car reviews will give at least an indication of what age group a car might suit – or what uses it’s best for.

Car manufacturers have thrived by understanding that the market has driven new and different requirements from them. Reading that demographic data – and being able to make sense of it – has allowed them to remain relevant. Reverse engineering that data – perhaps your own data – can help you understand which car is really right for you.

In The Black

Diesel engines are under the microscope for their pollutants – so what do you need to know?

Attention has been slowly but surely turning towards diesel cars, as European capitals including London register worrying levels of particulates in the atmosphere. The reason is fairly simple. While diesels are heralded for their low levels of carbon dioxide – at least compared to petrol – they emit other nasties such as particulate matter, plus nitrogen and suplhur dioxides that are bad news for those suffering from respiratory illnesses such as asthma.

The question is, having incentivised the take-up of diesel engines through attractive tax rates for fleet and business users in an attempt to reduce CO2 emissions – diesel and petrol sales for new cars are close to parity these days – will the EU now legislate to punish diesel drivers?

Not likely. The vast amounts of cash tied up in creating more efficient diesel technology have driven down CO2 emissions and scrubbed a lot of the nasties in more advanced catalytic converters, virtually eliminate turbo-lag and made driving an oil-burner as refined as a petrol. As such the car industry – not to mention the oil industry – would view that very dimly.

There’s another problem. Homologation – a posh word for standardisation – means that all emissions tests run in laboratories to ensure a level playing field. But – as a result – the figures bear little similarity to the reality. For the same reason you will rarely achieve anything like the official fuel economy on any car. The EU has recently realised that not only are its emissions figures for diesel pollutants wrong, they’re so wrong that current cars could never hit modern pollution targets. This means there’s a very real possibility that, despite recognising the danger to public health posed by diesel fumes, emissions targets could increase, rather than decrease before 2020.

Confused? Join the club. My advice is not to worry if you’re considering buying a diesel – or even a fleet of them, as emissions targets are unlikely to affect you anytime soon. But do service diesels properly, make sure they get regular long runs at motorway speeds to burn off nasties and ensure drivers understand the benefits of eco-driving. Diesels may be complicated machines, but they’re still machines. As ever, it’s how we use them that counts.