Group Test: Superminis

A group test of three superminis, written for Professional Manager magazine

Suzuki Swift

One of the more individual Supermini on the road, the Swift is also one of the smallest, though all models boast five doors. That, along with its firmish suspension, makes it great for chucking around but it also means that it doesn’t need a beefy engine. The 1.3 DDIS diesel has lots of torque low down – a very impressive 140 pound feet – so never feels laboured and it can also return 72mpg.

On SZ4 spec it wants for nothing – including a whopping seven airbags, Bluetooth connectivity, cruise control and automatic air conditioning – meaning this is one of the best cars in the sector for providing bang for your buck. Do consider the cheaper petrol 1.2 engine though – the diesel premium may not be worth it for smaller annual mileages.

All told the Swift is rather delightful, though. Yes it will keep the money men happy with its high fuel economy and low emissions but it’s a pleasant departure from the other cars in the sector too.

Good
The Swift looks lovely – an individual in a rather homogenous sector
Punchy diesel engine is not outgunned on the motorway
Excellent handling is a pleasant surprise

Bad
The Swift is undeniably small – boot size is 211 litres only
Premium for diesel may not be worth it
They couldn’t quite squeeze it under 100g/km

Citroen DS3

Certainly the looker in the segment, people thought Citroen were mad to lend their coveted DS badge to a series of re-engineered models. But no-one’s laughing now. The DS3 is one of the best cars on the road, period, with superb looks inside and out, a range that includes some of the best engines in the world and a reputation for tempting user-choosers into French metal.

Why? Well, the 1.6-litre Airdream model can return a gnat’s whisker short of 80mpg, emitting a lowly 91g/km of CO2 on the way. That means zero road tax and zero congestion charge – for the time being anyway. DSport trim is blingy and useful – with Bluetooth, leather interior, black alloys, cruise control, chrome styling touches and sculpted front seats.

If that’s not enough head up the model range for the THP petrol engines. But if you can’t afford them the DS3 is pretty much as good as it gets in this sector for style with more than a dash of common sense.

Good
Boot space is nudging up towards 300 litres
One of the best-driving Supermini on the road
Stunning looks; highly customisable

Bad
Rear space is indifferent
Some buyers may find performance doesn’t match styling
Higher specced models are rather pricey

Honda Jazz

Something of an elder statesman in the sector, the Jazz is the largest Supermini on the block and quietly reliable too. No head-turner, this one, it just does the job it’s required to do while raising an eyebrow at the more expansive models in the sector.

The ace up the sleeve is the Jazz’s 399 litres of boot space – a phenomenal amount that put may much larger cars to shame. The bulletproof engine, excellent build quality and rather gentle road manner may also appeal to a certain kind of buyer.

Despite only offering a petrol engine, the 1.4-litre lump is capable – it returns over 50mpg and never feels outpaced. – but there’s a hybrid available too. The Jazz may be getting on a bit but it can still show the youngsters some moves.

Good
Massive interior space for a car in this sector
Superb build quality
Hybrid model may be a big, green tick for eco-minded fleets

Bad
Conservative looks and handling may not inspire
Prices are heavy at high specs
The Jazz is not in the first flush of youth

Don’t skirt the Minis

My Q2 column for Professional manager magazine – on the rise of Supermini cars and their appropriateness for the fleet sector

As with many walks of professional life, it’s easy to get drawn into spotting patterns in data when you work in the car industry. With a wealth of figures available every month from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) few journalists can resist writing the epitaphs of car makers seemingly on a downward slump – or lauding those registering huge jumps in sales.

Yet there are always long-term patterns that may contradict short-term gains or losses – and car sales shouldn’t be the only consideration is registering the health or relevance of a manufacturer when a lack of new product, external factors such as petrol prices and a shift in focus to more profitable models could lurk behind the headlines figures.

Having said that a look at 2013’s car sales, within the context of the last ten years or so, indicate that talk of a financial recovery may not be far from the mark. Car sales in the fleet sector – often a good arbiter of the general health of the industry – were up some 25% on the previous year. Even allowing for a three-year bounce from the end of the scrappage deal that’s very good news, though the overall figures have only just reached parity with 2007, the last full year before the credit crunch zapped car sales.

There are, however, some undeniable, patterns across that period of time. Strip out the false positives and there’s a definite trend in car sales towards a narrow band of car segment to the detriment of virtually every other. By 2014 it’s evident that the once-humble Supermini – and similar ‘crossover’ cars based on the same platforms as cars such as the Ford Fiesta and Vauxhall Corsa – is where the smart money is in a landscape where the cost of living is squeezing real wages and costs. Sales in this sector now account for 35% of all registrations in the UK – and that figure is growing.

These cars were once considered entry-level, below even the informal Small Family Car tag of the Honda Civics and Volkswagen Golfs as far as body segments are concerned, and are only trumped by the City Car – the cheapest, smallest cars on the road today. Yet as car safety, aerodynamics and the demands of versatility and practicality have increased, the Supermini has grown in size and stature. There’s nothing humble about these cars any more.

These cars are everyday heroes at the sharp end of modern manufacturing. Margins are razor thin in this competitive marketplace so these small cars must fulfil the functions that much larger cars used to. The modern Supermini will be expected to transport at least four adults, plus luggage, in comfort – not a problem in cars such as the Honda Jazz; at 399 litres it puts many larger cars to shame. Practicality is not a premium in the sector; most model offer the choice between three or five doors and most have versatile seating arrangements.

Nor should the modern Supermini want for the variety of modern gizmos that car owners expect as a matter of course: satellite navigation, Bluetooth, cruise control, DAB radio and the requisite safety equipment. Most cars in this sector are equipped with a fleet special – the car designed to tempt the fleet manager to look again – that will be packed with the sort of kit designed to keep drivers happy on long journeys.

Just as important these days is fuel economy on these small cars, where relative size and weight is a natural advantage. In 2007 average CO2 emissions from new cars was 164.9g/km; in 2013 it was 129.1g/km – a stupefying drop aided by the take-up of Mini and Supermini cars. Put another way, a typical new car is now 27% more efficient than seven-year-old model. Combined fuel economies of over 75mpg and emissions of under 100g/km are routine in this sector – while modern small cars frequently offer an automatic transmission with little fuel penalty.

At least one model that offers these tax-busting, wallet-friendly powertrains will be present in the line-ups of all mainstream manufactures – and even some you might not expect. Audi’s A1 is the German premium offering in the sector and Citroen’s DS3 represents the funkier end of the market. Small cars are no hair shirt these days.

High-spec, good-looking and affordable cars should be the holy grail for fleet managers and the Supermini has been shaped by the demands of the market; demands that are often contradictory. More space; less weight. Higher economy; lower emissions. Because of these unique demands the Supermini is a marvel of packaging and technology.

We’re hard-wired to see patterns in data or experiences that may be meaningless. But in automotive terms it’s clear that this trend isn’t a figment of imagination. Small cars are big news – in a smaller, cleaner, cheaper future that makes them impossible to ignore.

Mini Marvels

Five tips to ensure Superminis work for your fleet

In three year’s time

Not all Superminis are born alike – high-spec models will offer the best residual values so don’t go for entry-level metal if this is a consideration.

Don’t dread unleaded

Fuel economy is impossible to ignore, but do bear in mind that many modern petrol engines can offer excellent MPGs. On smaller, cheaper cars the diesel premium may not be worth it.

Three-door bad; five-door good

All Superminis feature a hatchback tailgate, but think of your rear passengers and make sure you get front and back doors too.

Don’t fear the badge

Old-fashioned badge snobberies make little sense at the best of times but all manufacturers are developing rapidly. Look again at that brand you’re inclined to dismiss.

Baby got back

Modern Superminis are expertly packaged – some will offer larger boots and interior space than much more expensive cars. Don’t assume those golf bags won’t fit in the boot.