Loving The Alien: Honda Accord Tourer review

I once edited a review that started with a vague surprise at the continuing good form of the Accord, not to mention the fact that it was continuing at all. In a segment that has been shrinking as long as I’ve been writing about cars (seven years and counting), the traditional D-segment saloon / estate seems anachronistic. Oh, Laguna, where art thou?

Indeed, the Accord Tourer seems a car rather out-of-time. The interior feels a generation old in that way that a well-looked-after car belonging to an older relative does (or, in fact, an older relative does). The leather seats are sumptuous and the interior feels large, but the displays seem dated; they look a bit clunky – somehow analogue in a digital age.

Six years on from launch and the exterior is smart but clearly not in tune with the most recent design dynamic, looking rather chunky and boxy when compared to the rest of the current D- and E-segment offerings. There’s nothing especially bad about that – the Accord Tourer continues to look futuristic, in the way that a rocket ship in a 1980s sci-fi film looks futuristic and a little bit insectoid, alien – different from anything else on the road.

It was designed specifically to be an estate, rather than a saloon with a box stuck on the end of it and it shows. Paradoxically the amount of storage space has nosedived to barely 400 litres; about 200 litres less than the previous model – absurdly it’s less than the saloon offers to boot, as it were. This makes no sense whatsoever. Personally, because I’m a contrarian idiot, I’m very fond of it.

Musings of this kind on Honda models are nothing new, but it’s a subject that intrigues me. Oh, you can keep your torque curves and Bilstein dampers and Watts linkages – I couldn’t care less. You could show me the equations that prove the respective Audi or VW models are superior. It wouldn’t make any difference. How people relate to cars, what drives them to buy and love one car or spurn and deride another is what gets me. What meaning, what emotion, what significance do we project onto our cars – and why?

I love my Ford Puma – so much so that I sucked up the expense and put it through its MOT for another year, against all logic – and am always grateful to get back into it after a spell with a press car, regardless of the quality of said metal. I think it suits me and I suit it. I have moulded to its shape, handling and style. I can’t imagine not owning it.

The Puma does have a lot going for it. It’s a fine front-wheel drive car for hooning around and it’s the best-loooking of Ford’s late-90s idiom (New Edge, even the words sound 90s). But it’s not one of the best cars ever made. In some ways it’s rather shoddily and illogically made, prone to rust (courtesy, supposedly and probably apocryphally, of a batch of rubbish Polish steel used by Ford around the time) to the point where Paul, my local mechanic and the man who has probably spent the most time with the Puma bar me, was driven to ask if it had spent its life by the sea, or possibly in the sea. The Dead Sea, perhaps.

The rear space is pointless, the ride is bumpy and unsettled on poor road surfaces. To fold the back shelf (at an angle of about 30 degrees) you have to simultaneously pull two release cords on the rear of the boot while pushing the rear bench down. This is literally impossible unless you use your head to knock down the rear shelf. I do. The heat shield fell off one day, the car has a clever internal irrigation system, replacing parts is a ballache. You get the picture.

Yet I defend the Puma constantly. Once I replied to a man who called it a ‘girl’s car’ (true, perhaps, but reductive and meaningless) by calling him an idiot. Yet the Vauxhall Tigra is a girl’s car in my book. It’s far inferior to the Puma in every respect, yet there’s a man who owns a Tigra somewhere calling me an idiot. Which of us is right?

Which of us is right on any judgement call on a car? The car mags generally have it that Volkswagen is better than the rest of the volume market and that Hyundai and/or Kia has caught up with the Europeans. Bollocks. Every Kia or Hyundai – despite their efforts, for which I salute them – I step into crushes the soul out of me. They’re crap to drive, crap to look at, crap to experience. Oh, sure, they’re have generous warranties and competitive specifications, but they are noticeably inferior cars to the majority of European and Japanese cars, to me anyway. I recently drove both the Kia Optima and Hyundai Veloster. I thought them fine-looking cars. Then I drove them and I never wanted to see them ever again.

VW is not superior to the rest of the sector. It’s pretty debatable whether Volkswagen is superior to Seat and Skoda, its notionally inferior (certainly cheaper) sister marques. Yet the idea persists that Volkswagen cars are the best you can buy. Do JD Power surveys or customer satisfaction surveys tend to back up this notion? No, they don’t. You know who does well in these surveys, year after year? Of course you do.

I can’t quite explain what I love about Honda cars so much, despite the fact that I don’t especially like their clearly aging parts, engines, transmissions. There’s just a feeling of utter serenity about them; a reassuring solidity; a soothing calm. The Accord Tourer is like a 70s David Niven, getting on a bit yet radiating a kind of effortless, understated charm. Honda cars feel comfortable with themselves.

The Accord estate looks and feels well built and has an air of reassuring serenity on the motorway, though the ride starts to feel unsettled at higher speeds. The boot that’s no match for the sector leaders, due to the car’s streamlined styling. Nor is it the best inside, with the car’s sharp exterior styling intruding significantly on interior space and evidence of cash-saving on some parts.

The 2.2-litre diesel engine is powerful and refined, though running costs aren’t particularly impressive – not as much as you might expect anyway, another example of slightly aging technology. I didn’t achieve anything like the official mileage of 50mpg. Prices aren’t especially low either – the Accord Tourer 2.2 i-DTEC EX AT costs a night out shy of thirty grand. The price reflects that notional barrier between Honda and the rest of the volume players – the Fords, Vauxhalls and Renaults of the market – supposedly a gnat’s wing behind. Are they? Does a price point that puts the Accord Tourer on a par with Audi, BMW, Mercedes and Lexus make sense? Well, it depends who you ask.

In much the same way, views on the Puma depend on who you ask. To many petrolheads the car is almost beyond reproach. To others, it’s simply a girl’s car on a Fiesta chassis. No-one who’s uninterested in cars is even the slightest bit impressed by it. The same might be said for many other fine cars on the roads today – and while the Accord Tourer’s vagaries and eye-watering asking price mitigate against it there will be people who buy one and will love it for all its faults, not despite them.

Honda Accord Tourer

Honda Accord Tourer 2.2 i-DTEC EX AT
Engine: 148bhp 2.2 i-DTEC
Price: £29,845
CO2 Emissions: 146g/km
Combined Fuel Economy: 50.4mpg
0-60: 10.7 seconds
Annual VED: £140

An Astra For Everyone: Vauxhall Astra SRI

Rather like successive iterations of the Starship Enterprise, the Vauxhall Astra has changed beyond all recognition over the years. The last version was a rather frumpy hatch that was beaten into submission by the superiority of the last Ford Focus; dull to look at, dull to drive and destined forever to be the sort of car you’d be dismayed to find is your latest fleet or rental car. Before that a kind of shatchback with some vague stab at the classic ‘three boxes’ saloon shape and before that a genuinely crap car.

I feel like I’ve driven more Astras than any other car over the last few years. I would guess that I’ve driven just about every version of this current Astra, many iterations of the previous model and about half a dozen oddities from Vauxhall’s heritage collection at a selection of launches and a recent trip to the heritage fleet in Luton. Twintops, Triple 8s, VXRs, GTCs, three-doors, five-doors. It’s only a surprise there’s no genuine saloon; the Jetta to GM’s Golf. In an idle moment I once waded through the CAP data to see how many derivatives there were (body styles, specs and engines) – the sum was awe-inspiring.

The first time I drove the Mark 6 Astra was a quick trip out in a 113bhp 1.6-itre petrol – a longserving General Motors lump that always feels too weak and insipid. The next time I took one out is was with one of the General’s impressive 2.0-litre turbodiesels and the difference was staggering – I revised my opinion of the car significantly, possibly accompanied by appropriately raised eyebrows and a chin being stroked. One of the first reviews of the Audi R8 I read concluded with a report on all the assembled journos quietly nodding their appreciation. Perhaps I did something similar, in a car-park in Huddersfield.

Having since driven the GTC up two of Britain’s more exacting hillclimbs (fourth last) and the VXR around Rockingham (third last) in my undistinguished motorsports career I can vouch for the superiority of their respective engines, even if the latter is compromised by a little too much power. My most recent experience with an Astra came in the form of the uprated 177bhp 1.6 petrol and, oddly, it’s a bit of a cracker.

My point is this. It’s easy to judge a car on its engine – I do it all the time as, presumably, do most of us who enjoy giving our cars a thrash. But to judge a car on its engine alone is as daft as assessing a potential life partner on the quality of their digestive system. When people ask me whether a Kia cee’d or Mazda3 they’re sizing up is any good they very rarely ask me how to explain the power delivery on said model, nor do they question the suspension set-up or amount of torque and its delivery. In fact I suspect that, when I ever mention torque to the ‘not-we’ they think I’m referring to speech, as if I believe myself to be in some sort of verbal communion with the car I’m waffling on about.

Car buyers don’t give two hoots about these things. In my extensive research into the subject (remembering what people ask me) I suggest the following priorities of roughly 97 per cent of the car-buying population comes down to list price, running costs, safety, kit and styling. Acceleration is somewhat down the list, slightly ahead of ‘free floor mats’ and ‘colour of dipstick’.

Vauxhall has clearly thought about this – the SRi looks really good with a lovely red paintjob and massive alloy wheels that totally ruin the ride, although the suspension means that it can handle some abuse. The interior looks good too – it’s another car that makes me question the supposed superiority of Volkswagen in this sector. So, Vauxhall has that one ticked off.

The engine too, in theory. While responsive it’s the suggested combined fuel economy of almost 40mpg that should put it on the radars of people who look at running costs. But it doesn’t quite stack up – as few official mileages do – in the real world. I’d guess somewhere around 33mpg is more likely and who buys a car with 180bhp to pootle around at 67mph? This touches on some doubts I have surrounding the Ecoboosts of this world – there’s a cognitive dissonance for me with these petrols that can be sporty and economical; will any driver be able to balance the two? I’m willing to believe that they’re either / or. But both? It doesn’t seem likely.

I suspect that, regardless, many people will take to the Astra in its 1.6 180PS SRi guise – it’s a car that looks nice, apparently offers decent running costs (though the fact that CO2 doesn’t sneak under 160g/km is a puzzler), is safe and drives well. It has its problems – the boot is fairly small for the sector, the large alloys look great but ruin the ride and the fuel economy flatters to deceive.

But will it matter? I don’t think it will. Donald Rumsfeld made a rod for his own back when he talked of unknown unknowns – the things ‘we don’t know that we don’t know’. In the case of car buying ignorance is frequently bliss. Will it matter to you that you’re not getting 41.5mpg or have a car that’s quite the match of sector leaders in terms of ride/handling balance? Of course not, you’ll have a shiny new car that won’t kill you, fits in five and makes a nice noise when you go fast.

If not, well there are plenty of other Astras out there to suit your wallet, your self-image and your day-to-day needs. In that sense buying a car becomes not just a matter of which manufacturer and model, but which derivative within a particular range. There’s probably an Astra to suit virtually ever car-buyer out there. Among the specs and engines and body styles an Astra, if you will, with your name on it.

Vauxhall Astra

Astra SRi Hatchback 1.6 Turbo 16v (180PS)
Engine: 178bhp 1.6-litre 4cyl petrol
Price: £20,700
CO2 Emissions: 160 g/km
Combined Fuel Economy: 41.5mpg
0-60: 7.9 seconds
Annual Road Tax: £170